Photo: Boston Society of Architects
This open staircase is pretty cool. Unless you are wearing a skirt.
A recent twitter series gave me a laugh. It sure shows how your perspective may change with a change of clothes.
At the Los Angeles Times, Carolina A. Miranda wrote how she hit a nerve with one frustrated tweet.
“A couple of weeks ago, after viewing an architectural schematic that featured a pair of elevated glass catwalks, I posted a tweet that invited male architects to navigate their own designs in a skirt.
Carolina A. Miranda
@cmonstah
Idea: All male architects should be required to navigate their own buildings in a skirt.
“The post ignited a flurry of responses from women, including Mary McNamara, Los Angeles Times assistant managing editor and former television critic, who suggested adding heels to the mix. To that challenge, design writer Alissa Walker of Curbed added babies. …
“I took [a picture] at the Nicanor Parra Library at Diego Portales University in Santiago, Chile, in 2015. The building was designed by Chilean architect Mathias Klotz and was completed in 2012 — in other words, at a point in time when male architects should know better. Yet the library features glass floors in locations throughout the building. …
“John Hill, who writes the blog ‘A Daily Dose of Architecture,’ pointed out the use of see-through walkways in Rafael Viñoly’s building for the architecture school he designed for the City College of New York — which he completed in 2009. City College isn’t the only school of architecture to employ transparent walkways. …
“This not only affects the women who work and study in those buildings — according to the Assn. of Collegiate Schools of Architecture, 42% of accredited architecture degrees were awarded to women in 2013 — but it normalizes the idea among architecture students that transparent walkways are just a benign architectural feature. They are not. …
“In 2010, technology writer Joanne McNeil wrote about this very topic in a post that ran on her blog ‘Tomorrow Museum,’ later reprinted by Mediaite.
” ‘If I were commissioning the interior of any kind of store and someone brought me blueprints including glass staircases, I’d tell him to take a hike,’ she wrote then. ‘I wouldn’t give him a second shot. If he’s not intuitive enough to grasp that women in skirts will be uncomfortable walking upstairs, clouded glass or not, then what other errors has he made in his design?’
“So, if there are a few good men out there (within driving distance of Los Angeles) willing to walk around one their own or someone else’s buildings in a skirt — while wearing high heels and holding a purse and a baby — my lines are open.”
More here. Let me know if you have encountered similar architectural challenges. Although I wear pants more often these days, I have memories of negotiating the green staircase above in a skirt — uncomfortably.
Yes, indeed! Hard to imagine that something this obvious would need to be explicitly explained to male architects… yet obviously it does!
I wonder if there are glass floors in Scotland, considering that a good number of Scottish men wear kilts.
Haha! I was about to suggest getting a Scottish man to do it too! 😊 Let’s just hope he doesn’t walk over that Marilyn Monroe vent!!
We should introduce kilts around the world. They are cooler in summer. And they might improve architecture.
😂 Yes! And men will stop sitting weird at airports!
Ha, ha, ha. Manspread.
I like your way of responding to responses.
Well, that story was just so much fun. I am looking for more stories that make me laugh.
40% of architecture degrees go to women and this isn’t something that’s talked about in every course they take?! That amazes me.
Good question!
It’s one of the reasons the world needs more female architects. I believe considering different experiences of people is necessary for a good design – unfortunately many women who studied architecture end up working in different fields. More variety would be beneficial for us all.
I would be interested to hear what fields women who studied architecture without continuing ended up choosing.
That’s a good question. The statistics are mostly focusing on them leaving the profession gradually, but not really following their later paths. But I assume like men they usually choose other creative fields.