
Photo: Benedict Evans/The Guardian.
This is 826 Valencia Street, San Francisco, the center for young writers that author Dave Eggers co-founded in 2002.
Authors in general are not OK with the way artificial intelligence undermines the value of human creativity. They also notice faster than the rest of us when AI begins to impinge on our thought processes.
In a long, discursive Guardian interview, Sophie McBain finds that acclaimed author Dave Eggars is not going to take it lying down. She writes, “Eggers had thought, over two decades of working with children, that he had met and seen every educational challenge. Then AI entered the classrooms.
” ‘The AI challenge really is beyond an existential one. Every time I think I’m going to talk to somebody who would never deign to use AI in any form I find there’s this very porous line where, you know, a smart 10-year-old will say, “Well, I don’t use it to write, I just use it to generate ideas,” which is far, far worse.’
“When he hears stories like that, he likes to remind students of their uniqueness. ‘You’re one of one,’ he’ll say. ‘You’re unprecedented in the entire line of human history. Only you have your brain. Only you can think of what you can think of. Only you can tell a story in a particular way. Why would you cede that to a machine?’
“Eggers’s voice, usually quiet, almost monotone, rises as he warms to his theme. ‘Once you have a machine think for you and write for you, you’re cooked as a species. That’s it. That’s the worse dystopian outcome there could ever be,’ he says. He can think of nothing worse than ‘the idea of us willingly, without any overlord telling us so, saying, “I think my voice would be better expressed by an unthinking machine who has plagiarized all of the world’s authors and has come up with this terrible soup of bad writing.” ‘
“For all the dispiriting news about AI-written books and reviews, Eggers believes that eventually there will be a countermovement, much as there is growing resistance to giving teenagers smartphones and social media access.
“Most teachers, he suspects, understand the problem with tech in schools. The problem stems from policymakers. He mentions a speech in which the US education secretary Linda McMahon talks about the benefits of introducing AI into schools, even for children as young as five. …
“Eggers and his wife, the writer Vendela Vida, are part of two class action lawsuits against Anthropic over the AI firm’s unauthorized use of their books to train large language learning systems. ‘I guarantee you they didn’t even think they were stealing anything because it’s just “content” to them,’ he says. Content is the ‘world’s worst word,’ he adds, because it dehumanizes writing and suggests ‘it has no real value inherently, and it doesn’t matter if humans made it or not.’
“He has written two dystopian novels, The Circle (2013) and The Every (2021), about a monopolistic big tech firm that is trying to take over every aspect of human existence, and somehow reality seems capable of outdoing his imagination.
“In The Every, the president communicates in emojis, rather than rightwing memes, and AI is used to sanitisze novels, rather than write them from scratch. He was recently invited by Sam Altman of OpenAI to speak on campus about AI-written novels.
“To everyone’s credit, Eggers says, it was an interesting, open conversation. ‘It was a really nice afternoon, actually, because what we always forget is that the maniacal illusions of a few of the people at the very top are not always shared by the rank-and-file … at least some of the people working there do want to be told what’s right and what’s wrong,’ he says. ‘But I definitely did have to give them the bad news … there’s no such thing as AI art. Only humans can create art.’ At best, the stuff a machine can spit out can be described as ‘computer generated imagery.’ “
More from Dave Eggers at the Guardian, here. A likeminded author, Margaret Atwood, calls AI “garbage in, garbage out,” at Deadline, here. You can probably come up with many more examples.













